Trestle, Embraced by the Foggy Breath of Dawn
by Skip

Comment:
Nice. Background is too blown though, needs a bit of adjustment. Might've been nicer as sepia, duotone or b&w.

Whistling Straits
by sbeaumont

Comment:
Screaming out for a different angle, without the people. Otherwise, fine.

Gravity Well/Event Horizon
by GeneralE

Comment:
Very arty. I'm not sure about the centre point though, it doesn't seem distinct enough to be worth looking at. What actually is the subject in this photo?

Split Reality
by trnqlty

Comment:
I like the creation of false parallel lines via the reflection, I think its an interesting twist on the challenge. Composition is good. However something seems a wee bit 'flat' about the image, I'm not sure what it is. Perhaps it would've been better in B&W with a touch of contrast. I also would've preferred it without the people, but that's down to personal preference.

Greater DOF might've made the 'vanishing point' seem more significant.

7

Ok so wheres' Thomas?
by pearcer

Comment:
Good exposure and the subject is excellent, meets the challenge spot on, and good fun.

Maybe I'd have composed it differently, perhaps with something which emphasises the scale a bit more dramatically.

The Heart
by Manish Shrivastava

Comment:
Lighting and colours are amazing, composition is nice but losing the bottom of the glass is slightly annoying. Personally would've cleaned the glass too, but regardless I gave it a 10. :)

God Gave Rock'n'Roll to You
by BooZon

Comment:
Top notch, the lighting really finishes it off. 9.

Leaves
by riley

Comment:
I really like the glow on the background leaf, but it distracts slightly from the smaller version. It would've been nice to have the small leaf slightly sharper or brighter/darker to highlight it a touch more.

Background leaf looks like a surreal landscape with a forked road. I want to dive in and go exploring :).

Gave it an 8, probably deserved a 9 in retrospect.

Addiction
by digistoune

Comment:
I personally like the pink touch, makes the whole thing seem a bit more vintage. Like the inclusion of the "50mm" text in the main subject. Gave it a 10, thought it would go higher than it did!

Little Black Book
by tfaust

Comment:
I thought this would go much higher. Gave it a 10. Loved the background, lighting and b&w finish.