The Pretzel Guy
by Tranquil

Comment:
Greetings,
Just thought I'd offer my comments, The vendor looks great, focus is awesome on him, what bugs me about this pic though is the out of focus ....pretzels?...in the foreground. My eye keeps getting drawn to them instead of the vendor, perhaps because they are taking up a lot of the forefront of the pic. The pole on the left really doent bother me, nor does the background neither one detracts from the subject, but those pretzels.....(oh yeah and the bottle of what I assume is mustard on the lower right, but that is minor and I'm sure could be cloned out in PS). As to how to improve this shot, perhaps you could try it from a differnet angle, or perhaps shoot it when he is in "action" either preparing or selling a pretzel.....just my humble opinion...
Mike

Light at the End of . . .
by Kylie

Comment:
Wow, Very Interesting photo, would make a good print, although perhaps the person should be PS'd out, maybe....sorry 'bout the score though, it just doesnt say HOPE to me, despite being a great shot. If this had been say a Beach challenge I would have given it about an 8
Mike

seagull.jpg
by faidoi

Comment:
I love this photo, probably one of the best shots of a seagull I have seen, while the sharpness is awesome, I think it is the water that makes this shot, it appears so dark, empty and deep, plus seeing the ripples created by the gull moving across it is great!

Mike

Edith, the Train's Done Gawn
by Skip

Comment:
Greetings,
Great Pic, I like it a lot, reminds me of a railroad near where I grew up, only thing that bothers me a slight bit is the fog/lighting of the upper right corner, it seems a ittle overexsposed, perhaps PS could fix it up for you.....Still a great print!
Mike