Never a Day Without Charmin
by wwwavenger

Comment:
I'm looking for an almost instant advert hit - buy this! But what am i supposed to feel attracted towards here? Maybe Charmin is relevant? Don't know what it is. Technically though a fine image with effective framing and use of depth of field.

Outside in
by geewhy

Comment:
Easily best of the challenge. Superlative textures and the composition (using a window) is such an imaginative use of selective saturation. A thing of beauty. Well done. 10

The Wake Maker
by vtruan

Comment:
This is a compelling capture and with interesting and absorbing movement. I want to see more of this creature though and suspect from the noise that this might be a very tight crop of a larger original? it also lacks a focal point somehwere my eye is drawn. Naturally this might be the head but when I get there (being drawn by the arrow-shaped wake) I see a blurry shape underwater. 6

The Prudential Building, Buffalo, NY
by lwkimages

Comment:
Beautifully composed and edited. A real treat. My one quibble is that the sky has obviously been darkened and this leaves an unatural look to the boundary between sky and building as if you've just airbrushed the whole sky black. Not having sight of the original it's difficult to judge. Anyway - good work 9.

Frogs View at Twilight
by Neil

Comment:
Nicely observed and what wondrous colours, textures and framing. Well done. A particularly effective composition and use of colours in reflected sunset.

Sea terminus
by bpickard

Comment:
Nice composition and textures.. Colours apoear too saturated for my taste though and this I feel detracts from the image. The hues draw me into the stone flags rather than the viewpoint draw me out to sea.

High above the Earth
by jmritz

Comment:
What's the unusual viewpoint? Lying on your back or flipping the photo in the horizontal plane? Not sure this works as there is not enough in the image to retain any great attention.

the window
by ursula

Comment:
Fantastic. A compelling image.

Under the tripod
by movieman

Comment:
Good ide abut photo is poorly shot and out of focus. A tricky shot but you need to persist in your attempts.

822 Feet Up
by brownt

Comment:
It was nice weather in Edinburgh at the weekend wasn't it? A lovely shot with effective use of focal length to provide the right sense of space and freedom. Nice composition with figures and the sky adds greatly to a sense of drama. Only slight quibble is that it not that unusual a viewpoint - hilltops are fairly usual places from which to gaze. However, I'm not being too particular about this as what's usual to one person is unusual to another. Well done. (challenge you to spot my pic taken in Edinburgh:)))