Autumn Tapestry
by Neil

Comment:
Stunning! 10

A sticky end
by sidpixel

Comment:
A good choice of subject weakened by poor focus. Otherwise nicely framed.

The Horseshoe Crab
by Olyuzi

Comment:
This is a striking subject but as an image of a natural phenomenon, it is weakened by the artificial setting and the harsh lighting. Such a subject would be difficult, admittedly, to capture in nature but look closely at many ordinary things (trees, leaves, streams etc.), in varying lighting conditions and from all angles and you will find a subject that fits this challenge and conveys the idea of the humorous, bizarre or wondrous far more effectively that any staged shot.

The Famous Grouse
by bongo

Comment:
Beautiful capture with clear thought given to lighting which is key to an editorial shoot. Personally I find the background a bit odd and IMO the feathers distract a lot from the image. If they were Red Grouse dfeathers that might be different! Still an excellent shot. 9

SourceBook? Wishlist!
by pfellner

Comment:
A technically good shot but not sure what is being advertised - a key issue for an advert challenge.

Kodak EasyShare DX6340
by BooZon

Comment:
Excellent idea and would work well as an advert.

reassuringly expensive
by Harryg

Comment:
Good composition. Let down by wrinkled label and blown out highlights at base of glass. Feels refreshing though and thus communicates essence of a cool beer.

Before heading to work, I need my java.
by ladpupmoe

Comment:
Java? What;s java? Not knowing what it is the advert rather passes me by. Funny shot though and well executed.

Outdoor Type
by MAK

Comment:
Nicely shot. An effective advert though computer lacks sharpness - probably a consequence of 150kb submission limits. Well done.

Safe & Sane Refreshment
by SamT

Comment:
A good idea but fails to appeal as an advertising shot. Its the table covering that lets it down. Adverts usually have a strong studio feel if shot indoors.