Platform 4 (the way home)
by redmoon

Comment:
I made a pass on this image 4 times just because I'm not sure what to say. What I see is an image that's OOF everywhere. Not a single thing is in focus and perhaps the photographer is trying to convey something which I fail to understand. It's definitely using the flaws of technicality to bring out an artistic rendition.

Let me see.... train in motion, photographer is going home and probably in a rush to do it.
It maybe conveying the thought that this train will take me to my destination (home) but I don;t care about it and I wanna go now immediately (hence the motion blur)

Okay enough ramblin.... I give you a 7 for artistry.

The Bend
by docpjv

Comment:
Awesome. 10

Pacific Dreaming
by megryan

Comment:
Classic shot, lovely! 8

Spinning Her Way to Fun
by hyperfocal

Comment:
Nice and sharp where the sharpness should be. Great camera technique and works really well for this image. Great expression on the face and the catchlights are wonderful.

Rushing Home
by Warby

Comment:
This image has lots of leading lines to enjoy. Composition is not bad and meets the challenge perfectly. I see just a little bit of sharpness a couple of doors in front of the guy but the rest are blurry. Not sure if it was due to wide open aperture, shaky hands, low ISO or low light though the station is well lit. I've taken subway shots and almost always I had to up the ISO for faster faster shutter and keep my hands as stable as possible. 4

Around the Bend
by Skip

Comment:
Awesome and very striking image. I would've removed the arrow and the merge as the eyes tend to rest on them after following the red curved lines. 8

Sipping Wine on Cloud Nine
by Strikeslip

Comment:
well-done shot. I love the negative space. 9

Following the coastal path...
by Pixelstate

Comment:
awesome colors and very serene. 8

Picture 090edit1dpc.jpg
by pawdrix

Comment:
Nice candid shot. Love the warm colors.

All the old soldiers lined up in a row
by BrennanOB

Comment:
I love the (deliberate) horizontal slant of the horizon Nice color saturation. Good luck 7.