Inside my video tape
by heida

Comment:
Fits the challenge, though I think having the tape itself out would've added to the 'exposure' concept. Lighting looks good but the colors seem a bit flat and the photo didn't hold my interest very well. 5

Accessing my data
by agwright

Comment:
Nice crisp photo, good lighting. Curves vs the angular part of the piece is a nice contrast. I started with a 6 on this photo but after looking again it is starting to draw me in. revised vote to 8

Peeling Paint
by Konador

Comment:
I think the nature of the subject is good, the paint peel is in nice sharp focus. I would prefer a closer crop, as the length of gate/fence in the background is distracting with its soft focus. I think the thick white border also distracts a bit, perhaps if it were black and thinner. The lighting is great, gives the piece shine in just the right places. 6

The Emperor has no clothes ( Chewing Gum?)
by jmritz

Comment:
An interesting concept, the 'clothed to nude' progression is good but I find the photo doesn't hold my interest. I do like the idea though, and the lighting looks well done. 6

Exposed
by Jason

Comment:
Nice photo, fits the challenge well. I like the background, but I find the black & white aspect a bit flat. Would've liked all of the camera parts in the shot. Good focus on the camera. 5

Travel diary, lost en route
by johnmk

Comment:
I like the concept, but I find the picture to be a tad dark. IMO, it would add to the interest if the journal was buried a bit (either by leaves or in ground partially) and if the shot was a bit closer so you could read some of the wording clearly.

The gratuitous cat shot
by jab119

Comment:
I think your gratuitous cat shot is cute, has a playful air to it. Wish there was a bit more focus on the cats face/head, but that may just be the light on the fur. Fun photo.

Fall Colors Revealed
by alanfreed

Comment:
Gorgeous colors, wonderful view. Everything looks so crisp. I envy those out on the boat! Very nice land/seascape.

Out from the Shadows
by Nazgul

Comment:
I like the concept and the imagery the photo seems to be going for, but I don't like how the light is reflecting off the skin, it seems very mottled - it may be the gray tone of it. Still an arresting image.

Them Bones
by Firstrich1

Comment:
Great photo!. Lighting looks great too me, not overly done especially with the whiteness of the skull. I like the ruggedness of the photo, this works very well in black & white. Goes with the challenge in my mind too. Excellent job. 8