its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by ambaker:
Oh, you are probably getting slammed in the voting. But it gets a laugh from me. Grainy, a distracting highlight along the right side, and say isn't that the tip of your finger on the right? Still cute! If I were voting I would have given you a 6 for humor and bravery.

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by NikonJeb:
I have to give this a 3 for various reasons. I *am* trying to be constructive.......the split shadow/light isn't good, there's not anough contrast, the size is too small, and the focus is too soft. You *could* make this work.....it comes across to this viewer as an entry that not very much effort was put into it. I hate leaving visceral, harsh comments, but I am hoping that this will be of some use simply as an honest impression.

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by Purple_Girl:
Too small, very grainy and poor lighting.

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by epescala:
Really?

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by bobonacus:
A great unique idea, photo could be better quality though imho

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by Love6:
this is grainy- too small for me to really 'score' properly and tho the concept of a shadow-puppet is nice; it would have been more beneficial on a solid color bgrnd perhaps? (ie: white wall) the line down the 3rd of it is distracting to me; i hope my feedback is useful

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by bluefish:
I really like the idea of using a shadow puppet, but it is very grainy and the lighter right side is problematic for me. Good idea, though!

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by GThumbtack:
Not very big and the light leaves alot to be desired, but the simplicity and originality makes up for it.

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by stphq:
nice idea,, shame the photo looks like it was snapped on a camera phone

its a dog ( shadow puppet)
by bigcheech610

Comment by jomari:
It would be better with a bit more contrast and without the band of light on the right.